Tealeaf
Well-known member
raincloud said:If you are offering "favors" to get romantic/sexual attention in return, then you are a horrible person. Full stop. If you whine about it on the internet or unironically discuss the "friend zone" then you are a horrible person.
My reading comprehension skills are top-notch and I DID read the part about the "despite knowing that it's a display of romantic intention." How would that happen exactly? What is this hypothetical situation you envision where the woman KNOWS what the guy is thinking? Is he upfront? I'm imagining that a fellow just approaches a lady and says "I would like to take you out to dinner so that I can have sex with you later" and then she just takes the dinner and leaves. Frankly he deserves it. Are they going on a date and she decides she's not interested, and then she's "disrespectful" if he paid for dinner? People aren't vending machines where sex and love pour out after you put "favors" in. I read everything fine, it was perfectly clear. Where have I heard this line of reasoning before? Oh right, high school dudebros and adult misogynists.
The only thing I misinterpreted was the accusation that I'm a troll. Which I'm not.
It's a sad world that you live in and I feel sorry for you! But I admire your apparent mind-reading capabilities.
Also, Sci-Fi, I'm not defending your friends in this instance, but given what I've seen with all the "nice guys" on this message board (and Nice Guy defenders like the OP), a lot of ladies are wary of friendly behavior because apparently it means that angry dudes will whine about us on the internet for not having sex with them. Or, murder us. Whatever.
Most people have a little something called "social intuition". It's not flawless mind-reading, but they can tell what someone is thinking and feeling to an extent through their tone, body language, and context even if it's not something they're saying out loud. That means that sometimes women can tell that a man is interested even when he doesn't say so, and she could safely assume that if he's going out of his way for her that it's a way to try to get noticed or show off.
I just think that regardless of anyone's opinion on wah, wah, wah he deserves it! it's wrong to keep accepting. Thinking that someone is doing something wrong doesn't mean you should extract from them to your heart's content.
That's the only response I'm giving to someone like you, just in case someone confused but without an attitude comes along. Don't bother with more unless it's to someone else.
painter said:I suppose it depends what the favour/gift is. Each scenario could be different. If these favours or gifts are small things that people should be generally doing for each other anyway (holding doors open, offering a helping hand when someone is struggling blah blah) then it's fine to accept them, regardless of the other person's feelings/intentions. Small gifts too I guess. But there will come a point where I think it's this woman's responsibility to say "no, that's enough". In a perfect world she wouldn't have to but some people don't know when to stop.
I think of the guy in this scenario as a "nice guy". Maybe he is doing her favours and buying her things to win her over romantically, but not for the sole purpose of getting laid. That was my interpretation of it anyway.
I just think this topic was too closely related to it, and wouldn't be surprised if in the end it evolved to be about these things.
That's all I'm saying: that women shouldn't keep taking things from men in that scenario, let alone make excuses for why it's okay. Taking a misguided approach to romancing someone doesn't suddenly make them not a person, and his intentions could be pristine.