Paraiyar said:
Just because you don't agree with someone or you aren't telling them what they want to hear doesn't mean you lack empathy. I realize that I made a fairly blunt post towards Naizo but it's because I've seen this pattern with people on the forum before where it's obvious that they're definitely are creating their own problem whilst attributing it to everyone else. That may not be the case with Naizo for sure but the more I read his comments, the more I think it is the case. If it is the problem, I want him to snap out of it.
I've had some friends tell me some hard truths about myself this year and it's really improved my life in the long run. Sometimes the best thing is to tell someone something they don't want to hear.
That's right; disagreeing with someone doesn't necessarily mean you lack empathy - how you express your disagreement does. There are constructive ways to disagree with someone, and there are abrasive ways which will definitely not lead to the person taking your "advice" (although in this particular instance, I found your "advice" to come off more like an attack).
You say that it's "obvious" that he's creating his own problem, and then you add that "that may not be the case with" him. This, to me, doesn't seem like a good starting point for harsh personal criticism. It seems like you're basing your judgment on experiences with other people on this forum, and I don't really think that's far to Naizo. Nobody knows his problems better than himself, and if he says that a lot of people have treated him badly and that's made him angry, then it's kinda rude and condescending to jump in and say "you're the problem, everything is your own fault." Things are rarely that black and white (and that goes both ways).
I think I see where you're coming from, though. You want him to snap out of it, and I guess this was your way of trying to help. Someone did that for you this year and it helped you, so now you're trying the same. Wanting to help is good. But please keep in mind that people are different, and they react differently to various psychological methods (also depending on who it's coming from). Some people need "tough love," others need acceptance and validation of their feelings before they can even begin to work out the issues (whether it lies mostly with them or the people they've had bad experiences with). I would be careful with going straight for the "tough love" strategy unless I knew the person I was talking to, because if it's used on someone who's not ready for it, it can often do more damage than good. And I'm hoping that's not something most people on this forum wants to achieve.