Insightful or inciteful? If the latter than I agree. It's a new thread so that in itself makes it 'inciteful' versus the lack of them. Correct me if I'm wrong, people come here for the people and finding what they lack amongst other things. How this site looks really that strong of a factor? And if so,I dare say, are they actually desirable traffic then? Who knows but it certainly is not a redeemable quality.
Would it help? Considering the current state of the forum, it just might and I think the pros will out weight the cons. But, there's still very real problems to consider. The database is so large now due to it's age, to convert or upgrade may become very troublesome. Do we risk losing it ALL for the sake of upgrades? Then people might actually permanently leave. And is it cost effective, will it cause more stress on whatever server it is currently on? Older forums use a lot less bandwidth and put way less stress than newer. Last but certainly not least, maybe no one has any contact with the legitimate administrator or they have no desire to upkeep this site. Perhaps this site is purely only ran by the mods now and they have their hands tied behind their backs... I'm sure it's been thought of by many by now.