e.m.e. said:
Lost in the Oilfield said:
He only did what we wanted. He left us to work things out ourselves. He left us to our free will, just as we wanted.
I don't mean to argue with this, all religious world is pointing out "the free will" thing. For some reason unfortunately I doubt it now...how is fate a free will? ok this is crazy...but to sin we don't have a free will because we will be punished. How did Africa choose to suffer from AIDS?
this "free will" crap has been pissing me off for years now...
there were people that would rejoice, and there were people that would just harden their hearts and they would make excuses for what they saw.
I'm sure the suicidal person would defenately rejoice...
I guess there has been a first raw seat reserved for me in hell...lol
Hmm, first off your statement suggests strong emotionally biased "opinion", not factual information or referenced data that would class your statements as argument, so perhaps no matter what I say you won't care to hear, but I'll give it a go cause I'm crazy like that, weeeeeeeeeeee!
.
Ecclesiastes 2:14
The wise man has eyes in his head,
while the fool walks in the darkness;
but I came to realize
that the same fate overtakes them both.
Second, I think you are confusing definitions... maybe I'm just splitting hairs but:
Fate, in my studies are unavoidable conclusions to absolutes... your life will end in your death, sinners go to hell, Christians go to heaven. These are what I term as fates.
Free will is the ability to control or alter what is within your realm of influence (realm of influence is the sum of all things you are able to change... what you eat for breakfast, how you dress for school, whether or not to rob a store on the way to school) These are things you have control over. This is free will.
Now in relation to what I said before concerning free will... have you seen I, Robot? The master computer in I, Robot wanted to protect humanity from itself... the only way to do that was to utterly imprison and control the actions of humankind... that is restriction of free will.
Sin for the most part can be classed as any action that goes against the Commandments set out in the time of Moses. Just because you know something is a sin, and you know that there are consequences, doesn't mean you don't do it anyway... THAT IS FREE WILL.
e.m.e. said:
ok this is crazy...but to sin we don't have a free will because we will be punished.
Even knowing the consequences of our actions, we still have the will to choose to do actions with negative outcome... it may not be intelligent or sensible, but that is the very definition of free will...
to be free to do whatever we will.
e.m.e. said:
How did Africa choose to suffer from AIDS?
How does one respond to a question that is as a baited snare set before ones feet? What answer can one give to a question that is not a question at all, but a poisoned dagger in disguise?
How about this:
How did you choose to suffer (or not to suffer) from AIDS?
(makes about as much sense as yours)
Basically what I am saying is that with that very question you've completely escaped from reasonable or rational debate in this post... I'm sorry e.m.e but you've (perhaps unwittingly) created a trap for me that I have seen used many times before in a large number of different debates I've partaken in.
You created a post that doesn't really say anything at all concrete. Your meaning in your conclusion is left unclear so as to leave you a "back door" in the debate to slip through. You commit to nothing in your final question and looking at the question it is easy to see that it is not even a valid or rational one.
See, now if I were to take a stance and respond to your question based on what I "think" you are saying, you could return and say "oh this is what I meant" or "that is not what I meant" based on your counter to what information I provide in my response to your post. By answering this question, I open a Pandora's box of pointless questions and nonconstructive statements.
I'm sorry if that comes across rude or condescending e.m.e., but I've taken the journey that leads down that path too many times in the past... if the baiting was intentional, then you will take offense because you won't have enjoyed my response... if it was not, then you will probably take some time to clarify the meaning of your statements and your final question. Be wordy if you must, by all means, but put some thought into your statements. Try to ensure they make sense and are not strictly emotional, and I will gladly respond in kind.