Nice choice.Locke said:
Scotsman said:Jedward
You make some good points Leaning, but what I can't get past is how one person goes from this to this due to an illness. She looked perfectly fine in the "Before Picture"LeaningIntoTheMuse said:Reading more about this on Wikipedia (and I had never heard of her before), it sounds like she was schizophrenic and it was an incident of religious malpractice.
Not that I don't believe that the devil can possess people, but this was done in a time when mental illness was stigmatized and religious iconry made people believe that everyone who heard voices were possessed by spirits. I personally do not believe that she had demons inside her, she probably heard voices but this was because she wasn't treated with drugs.
If she were around today, she would have taken a mood stabilizer, and...voila, no signs of demonic infestation! This is religious propaganda at its very best, but it does make for a good story.
LoneKiller said:but what I can't get past is how one person goes from this to this due to an illness. She looked perfectly fine in the "Before Picture"
The autopsy report stated the cause of death as malnutrition and dehydration from almost a year of semi-starvation while the rites of exorcism were performed.[9] She weighed 68 pounds (30.91 kilograms). The previous day, she had broken knees due to the continuous genuflection and was unable to move without assistance, was reported to have been suffering pneumonia.[6]
A report into her cause of death stated that it was due to malnutrition and dehydration while the rites were being performed. This attracted an investigation, which concluded that she could have been saved if medical help was given even a day before. The parents and the two priests were charged, and the court case attracted much media and public attention. It has been called a misidentification of a mental illness, negligence, abuse and religious hysteria. After a guilty verdict, the defendants were sentenced to six months in jail but given three years of probation and a fine.