Jealousy...overrated?

Loneliness, Depression & Relationship Forum

Help Support Loneliness, Depression & Relationship Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
tedgresham said:
Actually I don't see a problem with being polyamorous. Seems like the way it would be if people really cared about each other unselfishly.

I don't think that polygamous form of relationship equates to being unselfish to your partner. Unselfishness is when you are able to spare some things you'd like to do to be able to be with the person you love and to make them happy. And both person involved in a relationship should be able to do that. Give in take so they say.

Besides, I don't think one person can love many people at the same time, there would always be that person he/she would love best. Notice in a polygamous culture most of them married one girl at a time, I haven't heard of a wedding with one groom and 3 brides and everyone was happy.
 
Polyamouse relationships as I experinced it. intails that all parties involved
agree to it.

The reason why it worked for me and the two women involved were Bi sexual

However where were tensions or jealousy between the women.
Becuase the first women I was with see me as her BF.
She wanted her cake and to eAt it too kind of thing.
She didnt want me to have anytype of emotional bonding with the other woman.
Or she would never leave me to be alone with the second woman.
Gradully becuase of the body contacts from threesome sex and just hanging out.
You tend to wanna get to know a person. Hence the emotional bonding.
Id come home and find the women in bed having sex sometimes.
And of course I'll ask if I can jump in bed with them too.lmao
I dont know what kind of stuff the girl talks about me when I'm not in their presence.
Gradually I started have sex with each women too indiviually.
Gradually I started having more bonding with the second women or spending more time with her.
It's beyound the sex...it's going out and doing things together.

Holi **** man....trying to keep a balance and maintaning 2 high maintenance women.lmao
Trying to keep a balance life style was fucken NULL.lol
Itt effected my other relationship in my life. I started spending less and less time with
my family and other friends. Thats all i had time for...sex all the time and these two women,
wheather I was with both of them at the sametime or with one of them at a time.
They totally wore out after a while.lmao

So my GF or my first thought I was cheating on her or the second women was stealing me....lmao
It's kind da hard to understand...cuase the two women also have a realtionship together.lol
Not in sexual terms but in relationship or emotional bonding terms.

K...as a guy. Being with the two women at the sametime .I didnt have any jealousy feelings for
them...if the hangout or have sex...

I still get jealouse if they talk to other men.lol
And its true for both of the women. They would hacve crazy looks in thier eyes if I talk to other women
beside them.
As i say....jealousy is a normal human emotion.

Im straight as an arrow. I'm really really into women.

Im wierd in this way...so you cant label me as a typical polymaouse...or maybe I understand things better now
that Im older and had sexual escaspade for a while....experinced things Ive never had until only 2 years ago.
I've alway been in monogamist relationships all my life...
I guess fail relationships after relationships would make me a polymaous in disguiss...IDK.
The reasoning is that I love a particular woman all my life and I guess it would take 100s of women to equal one of her.LOL
The twist in all of this or maybe things makesense now is....the love of my life is also Bi sexaul.
You also must understand over 20 years ago being gay or being bi-sexual wasnt acceptiable or out in the open as it is today.
So it kind da effect her in a lot of ways. She always felt she had to hide or there was something wrong with her for being Bi.
And I personally at that time wasnt so open to it or understood it. Still judgemental on peoples sexualality.
In a way it also created a weg between her and I. Now that I'm more understand because of my own personal experince,
I uderstand her more. i have more compassion for her. I was the one that was ignorant.

Yes they were times when she asked me if she could bring a girl home. i wasnt shocked or had a knee jerk reactions.
Or sometimes we go to strip joints becuase we still wanted our relations to remain monogamist
Id watch titays get rubbed in her face so she can releave her sexual desires for women.
Geeeze the fucken whizzz my family are all sexual perverts and sinners.lmao

 
Lonesome Crow said:
Polyamouse relationships as I experinced it. intails that all parties involved
agree to it.

The reason why it worked for me and the two women involved were Bi sexual

However where were tensions or jealousy between the women.
Becuase the first women I was with see me as her BF.
She wanted her cake and to eAt it too kind of thing.
She didnt want me to have anytype of emotional bonding with the other woman.
Or she would never leave me to be alone with the second woman.
Gradully becuase of the body contacts from threesome sex and just hanging out.
You tend to wanna get to know a person. Hence the emotional bonding.
Id come home and find the women in bed having sex sometimes.
And of course I'll ask if I can jump in bed with them too.lmao
I dont know what kind of stuff the girl talks about me when I'm not in their presence.
Gradually I started have sex with each women too indiviually.
Gradually I started having more bonding with the second women or spending more time with her.
It's beyound the sex...it's going out and doing things together.

Holi **** man....trying to keep a balance and maintaning 2 high maintenance women.lmao
Trying to keep a balance life style was fucken NULL.lol
Itt effected my other relationship in my life. I started spending less and less time with
my family and other friends. Thats all i had time for...sex all the time and these two women,
wheather I was with both of them at the sametime or with one of them at a time.
They totally wore out after a while.lmao

So my GF or my first thought I was cheating on her or the second women was stealing me....lmao
It's kind da hard to understand...cuase the two women also have a realtionship together.lol
Not in sexual terms but in relationship or emotional bonding terms.

K...as a guy. Being with the two women at the sametime .I didnt have any jealousy feelings for
them...if the hangout or have sex...

I still get jealouse if they talk to other men.lol
And its true for both of the women. They would hacve crazy looks in thier eyes if I talk to other women
beside them.
As i say....jealousy is a normal human emotion.

Im straight as an arrow. I'm really really into women.

Im wierd in this way...so you cant label me as a typical polymaouse...or maybe I understand things better now
that Im older and had sexual escaspade for a while....experinced things Ive never had until only 2 years ago.
I've alway been in monogamist relationships all my life...
I guess fail relationships after relationships would make me a polymaous in disguiss...IDK.
The reasoning is that I love a particular woman all my life and I guess it would take 100s of women to equal one of her.LOL
The twist in all of this or maybe things makesense now is....the love of my life is also Bi sexaul.
You also must understand over 20 years ago being gay or being bi-sexual wasnt acceptiable or out in the open as it is today.
So it kind da effect her in a lot of ways. She always felt she had to hide or there was something wrong with her for being Bi.
And I personally at that time wasnt so open to it or understood it. Still judgemental on peoples sexualality.
In a way it also created a weg between her and I. Now that I'm more understand because of my own personal experince,
I uderstand her more. i have more compassion for her. I was the one that was ignorant.

Yes they were times when she asked me if she could bring a girl home. i wasnt shocked or had a knee jerk reactions.
Or sometimes we go to strip joints becuase we still wanted our relations to remain monogamist
Id watch titays get rubbed in her face so she can releave her sexual desires for women.
Geeeze the fucken whizzz my family are all sexual perverts and sinners.lmao

I don't think the OP needs to know that, or anyone else for that matter. ^^
 
gypsytrip said:
Mayyybe I should've clarified. He CAN'T stay with me. I'm still in school so living with my parents, they would definitely not be okay with him staying here and he knows that.

BUT I still think it's very weird that he is staying with her. Especially since she only has one bedroom =/

Not to mention he is going to NY with her. He asked me too, but I can't go due to classes.

Staying with this girl aaand traveling alone to New York? Something's not right in my opinion. Friends or not.

Yeah, this screams to me that he really doesn't care about your feelings even if he's not doing something with this other girl (and it sounds like he is).

What kind of lousy boyfriend stays with another girl when he's got the opportunity to be with his partner? Urgh.

I'd cut this off before it really hurts you, he sounds like he's just treating you as "another prospect" rather than an actual girlfriend.

I also don't buy into this "long-distance" thing, sadly. I've seen so many people say that their "partner" just disappeared one day and got married to someone else, or they never heard from them again, or they don't see each other ever but still feel obligated to never date anyone else. Goes doubly if you've never seen them for real.
 
Good morning. It's sex. That's the ringer in this whole situation. I know I'm different but in my view there's a hell of a lot more to friendships/relationships than screwing. Sex is nice, sometimes. Sometimes it's not. But in the whole realm of relationships it has gotten way out of proportion. Are people jealous because their SO has a friend of the opposite gender or because they think their SO is screwing or wants to have some action. To some people, far too many of the younger generation, sex is a recreational sport. In that case, what difference does it make. There is no love or affection involved. To my generation it's supposed to be somewhat equated with emotional commitment. But whatever. The idiotic idea that so and so is "my man" or "my woman" is a cultural thing. It's been driven into our heads by centuries of christianity. We are programmed to couple up and be exclusive. I wish I could live long enough for us all to shake off that programming. I despise this culture that says if I go to lunch with a woman I am "cheating" or some such because I am married. That's just stupid. It makes it impossible for some people to seek out the type of friendships that they enjoy.

I would say that in a relationship we should trust not in the person's humanity but in their affection and commitment. Be happy when someone cares for you and appreciate the time you have together. Be happy for them if they have friends who make them happy.

I watched a British show recently where a relationship developed between a woman who was a doctor and bisexual and a guy who was extremely anti-gay. Once the woman struck up a friendship with another woman and the guy was all pissed off. She said something very profound. She said, "I don't love men or women, I love people." Would that we were all that way.

Probably off topic but a subject that makes me a little crazy sometimes, this "mine" and "yours" possessiveness of people. If somebody likes me, or loves me, I just say thank you. Their affection/love/friendship is their gift to me. But it is not a certificate of title. I do not own them and I do not want to own them and I do not want them to own me. It's all about giving. Unfortunately, giving is a lost art.
 
tedgresham said:
Good morning. It's sex. That's the ringer in this whole situation. I know I'm different but in my view there's a hell of a lot more to friendships/relationships than screwing. Sex is nice, sometimes. Sometimes it's not. But in the whole realm of relationships it has gotten way out of proportion. Are people jealous because their SO has a friend of the opposite gender or because they think their SO is screwing or wants to have some action. To some people, far too many of the younger generation, sex is a recreational sport. In that case, what difference does it make. There is no love or affection involved. To my generation it's supposed to be somewhat equated with emotional commitment. But whatever. The idiotic idea that so and so is "my man" or "my woman" is a cultural thing. It's been driven into our heads by centuries of christianity. We are programmed to couple up and be exclusive. I wish I could live long enough for us all to shake off that programming. I despise this culture that says if I go to lunch with a woman I am "cheating" or some such because I am married. That's just stupid. It makes it impossible for some people to seek out the type of friendships that they enjoy.

I would say that in a relationship we should trust not in the person's humanity but in their affection and commitment. Be happy when someone cares for you and appreciate the time you have together. Be happy for them if they have friends who make them happy.

I watched a British show recently where a relationship developed between a woman who was a doctor and bisexual and a guy who was extremely anti-gay. Once the woman struck up a friendship with another woman and the guy was all pissed off. She said something very profound. She said, "I don't love men or women, I love people." Would that we were all that way.

Probably off topic but a subject that makes me a little crazy sometimes, this "mine" and "yours" possessiveness of people. If somebody likes me, or loves me, I just say thank you. Their affection/love/friendship is their gift to me. But it is not a certificate of title. I do not own them and I do not want to own them and I do not want them to own me. It's all about giving. Unfortunately, giving is a lost art.

uhm, actually I don't think of it as that. When you are jealous of your partner being with someone else, as much as possible you want to be rational and fair but also, jealousy is not mere selfish feelings. It stems down from deeper roots, it concerns having low self esteem, it concerns the fear of not having the chance to make that person you love happy, it's being attached to that person that you fear by spending time with someone, they might develop special feelings to the other person. I know all these sounds naive and silly. But jealousy is a natural feeling, a natural reaction when you truly love a person and one can't solve it by looking only on the surface of it. It's not something that should be avoided or ridiculed, it's something to be face and overcome together with your partner.

Also, when I think of being a couple, it's not about two people having feelings for each other who have sex regularly. Being a couple is more than that. It means having a special bond with that person alone and by constant nurturing of your relationship, you grow together as one.

My example of this is the kind of relationship my parents have (I know this might sound funny to some) but my dad is a very aloof man, he is sociable but when it comes to his inner feelings, he rarely shows it. Even when growing up I was afraid to talk to him. But the things I admire about him is that the only person he would talk to about his inner most feelings is my mum. She is the only one he talked to about his pain when his brother (my uncle) died. She is the only person who knows how much growing up without a dad affected my dad so much (as my grandfather left his family to start another)

I know that I am possibly doomed to being hurt by keeping these ideals with me, but seeing their relationship while growing had just made it impossible for me to not believe or aim for that kind of relationship as well.

Also, polygamy is also a practice imposed on some cultures. Do you ever wonder what thoughts stream on women's mind who are wives of only one man? Religion has nothing to do with it, it's human natural emotions. And before Christianity, there were striving epics and stories of strong and passionate love with two people. There surely is something about a special relationship of two people that makes humanity be drawn to it. Even our dogs get jealous.

I'd never share my man, but along with that, I'd also do my best to keep him wanting only me. Selfish much? I don't care :D
 
Uh...LC...TOO MUCH INFORMATION!!!! Where's the bleach?

Anyway...jealousy is natural, everyone feels it at some point. It's the extremes you go to with your jealousy and how much you let it take you over. I dunno if I'd call what you are feeling jealousy though, sounds like you are more concerned that something might be going on. What do you have to be jealous about? You said he can't live with you, and obviously being a long distance relationship, and being in school, you can't go live with him.

The whole living with this other girl and going on a trip with her warrants concern, unless she's a lesbian. There are guys and girls who are just friends, I have several female friends that if I went on a trip with nothing would happen. Mostly because some are married so I wouldn't cross that line.

 
tedgresham said:
People's feelings get hurt anyway. Divorce is a national past time. Want to know about hurt feelings? I could write the book. But then feelings in this situation gets hurt quite often because, oops, someone starts to feel possessive. It's not a perfect world, of course, and people are going to be people, whatever relationships they are in. Friends, lovers, spouses, neighbors, family, whatever, hurt each other. In a better world there would be no pressure to be anything more than yourself and to accept others as who they are. Sharing, caring, loving without expectation. I'm just an old hippie out of time and place, I suppose. Radical, huh?

I am so not here to play, "I Bet My Story's Worse". I'm pretty sure everybody who uses this site could write the book on hurt feelings.

You're pretty fixated on this ownership thing, but that isn't what this is about. This isn't just, "Hey! I love you!" "Cool, thanks!" 'Cause I have that with friends. A romantic relationship is more than two people saying, "I love you." Just as marriage is a contract, a relationship is an agreement.

Each person comes into it with wants and needs to be met. They are saying, "I commit all of my affection to you and in return, you commit yours to me. We are each investing ourselves into this endeavor to be united." When somebody gets hurt that the other person is cheating, it isn't about some sense of entitlement or ownership. It's a betrayal of a trust and understanding.

Let us pretend that you go to a confectioner who makes chocolate peanut butter cups. You get there in time to grab the last one. They accept your money and you get the candy. This forms an agreement. "I give you money, and you give me peanut buttery chocolate goodness." You do not own the confectioner. The confectioner does not own you. Each of you has an understanding that you've each received what you want and need.

You leave your candy on a table while you run to the restroom. You get home and discover there is no peanut butter in your cup. You confront them. They admit that while you were away, they smeared your peanut butter onto a cookie for somebody else. Are you an ungrateful selfish jerk because you feel betrayed? Should you feel guilty for feeling angry?

*runs to the store for a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup*
 
floffyschneeman said:
uhm, actually I don't think of it as that. When you are jealous of your partner being with someone else, as much as possible you want to be rational and fair but also, jealousy is not mere selfish feelings. It stems down from deeper roots, it concerns having low self esteem, it concerns the fear of not having the chance to make that person you love happy, it's being attached to that person that you fear by spending time with someone, they might develop special feelings to the other person. I know all these sounds naive and silly. But jealousy is a natural feeling, a natural reaction when you truly love a person and one can't solve it by looking only on the surface of it. It's not something that should be avoided or ridiculed, it's something to be face and overcome together with your partner.

I can see what you're saying about self esteem. I agree that jealousy might come naturally to most people and that it should be faced and overcome. Facing a negative emotion and dealing with it is the only way to get past it.
floffyschneeman said:
Also, when I think of being a couple, it's not about two people having feelings for each other who have sex regularly. Being a couple is more than that. It means having a special bond with that person alone and by constant nurturing of your relationship, you grow together as one.

My example of this is the kind of relationship my parents have (I know this might sound funny to some) but my dad is a very aloof man, he is sociable but when it comes to his inner feelings, he rarely shows it. Even when growing up I was afraid to talk to him. But the things I admire about him is that the only person he would talk to about his inner most feelings is my mum. She is the only one he talked to about his pain when his brother (my uncle) died. She is the only person who knows how much growing up without a dad affected my dad so much (as my grandfather left his family to start another)

I know that I am possibly doomed to being hurt by keeping these ideals with me, but seeing their relationship while growing had just made it impossible for me to not believe or aim for that kind of relationship as well.

I agree. Older generations understood this far better than younger ones do. My home life was totally different, though. My dad was the most approachable, friendliest guy I've ever known. He was forever my best friend and I miss him severely even now. My parents, though, never hardly spoke. My mom was always critical and held grudges in a little pouch like a miser holds gold nuggets. Theirs was a relationship I could lever live with.

floffyschneeman said:
Also, polygamy is also a practice imposed on some cultures. Do you ever wonder what thoughts stream on women's mind who are wives of only one man? Religion has nothing to do with it, it's human natural emotions. And before Christianity, there were striving epics and stories of strong and passionate love with two people. There surely is something about a special relationship of two people that makes humanity be drawn to it. Even our dogs get jealous.

Christianity, and other religions, create boxes for people to live in. They create unnatural boundaries and restrictions. Just look at how same sex couples struggle these days in this insane Christian culture. Happy couples are fine as long as they're hetero.

It's great when two people find each other and have a passionate relationship. But then not everybody in the world is the same. Why should our culture define good/bad or right/wrong by what the majority thinks? I refuse to accept anything just because "it's natural" or "a part of our nature." A hundred years ago it was natural for a woman to slave for her husband and to beat your kids. These days we call that abuse, and rightly so. We all have a brain, an ability to be rational, to see things as they are.

Many would say it's natural for a guy to want to screw every women he can get his hands on. Does that mean it's ok? It's certainly not socially acceptable and not a good idea. And it's not in the nature of all men to be that way, just some. I'm rambling but the point is, so what it's "natural." Natural is not always good and should not be dismissed or accepted just because it's written into our genetic code.



 
tedgresham said:
Christianity, and other religions, create boxes for people to live in. They create unnatural boundaries and restrictions. Just look at how same sex couples struggle these days in this insane Christian culture. Happy couples are fine as long as they're hetero.

It's great when two people find each other and have a passionate relationship. But then not everybody in the world is the same. Why should our culture define good/bad or right/wrong by what the majority thinks? I refuse to accept anything just because "it's natural" or "a part of our nature." A hundred years ago it was natural for a woman to slave for her husband and to beat your kids. These days we call that abuse, and rightly so. We all have a brain, an ability to be rational, to see things as they are.

Many would say it's natural for a guy to want to screw every women he can get his hands on. Does that mean it's ok? It's certainly not socially acceptable and not a good idea. And it's not in the nature of all men to be that way, just some. I'm rambling but the point is, so what it's "natural." Natural is not always good and should not be dismissed or accepted just because it's written into our genetic code.

yeah I agree with what you're saying. but it could also be that people put people into boxes. we created these set of standards. after all, the old teachings of old religions would only rely on how a person understands them. I guess the point that I want to make is that some ideals (or standards) also have their beauty but it would depend on how people apply it. cos it's not for all and not for all situations.
 
nerdygirl said:
You're pretty fixated on this ownership thing, but that isn't what this is about. This isn't just, "Hey! I love you!" "Cool, thanks!" 'Cause I have that with friends. A romantic relationship is more than two people saying, "I love you." Just as marriage is a contract, a relationship is an agreement.

Each person comes into it with wants and needs to be met. They are saying, "I commit all of my affection to you and in return, you commit yours to me. We are each investing ourselves into this endeavor to be united." When somebody gets hurt that the other person is cheating, it isn't about some sense of entitlement or ownership. It's a betrayal of a trust and understanding.

Let us pretend that you go to a confectioner who makes chocolate peanut butter cups. You get there in time to grab the last one. They accept your money and you get the candy. This forms an agreement. "I give you money, and you give me peanut buttery chocolate goodness." You do not own the confectioner. The confectioner does not own you. Each of you has an understanding that you've each received what you want and need.

You leave your candy on a table while you run to the restroom. You get home and discover there is no peanut butter in your cup. You confront them. They admit that while you were away, they smeared your peanut butter onto a cookie for somebody else. Are you an ungrateful selfish jerk because you feel betrayed? Should you feel guilty for feeling angry?

*runs to the store for a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup*

I seems to me you're just saying something similar to what I am in a different way. Our views of what a relationship should be are entirely different. I have never entered into a relationship with the kind of expectations you have. Nobody owes me anything just because I love them. True love is given freely. It's a gift. When I give a gift it may or may not be appreciated but that's not the point. I love and/or care, depending on the relationship, hoping the same will be returned but never demanding it is. True love is not something we decide to have. It just happens. I hope it is returned but I would never demand it because it must happen in the other person. They cannot make it happen. If they do not have the same feeling for me then I have to accept that. If they do and I know it i do not worry about them, whether or not they will love someone else or have friends or whatever.

I might piss you off but I think what you said was rather sad. I love my wife. We do not have a perfect relationship, not relevant to this discussion, but the thing is, nothing she could ever do or say would change how I feel. She owes me nothing and I demand nothing. For over thirty years she has been the only person I've ever loved in this way. My wants/needs/desires are totally unimportant. This is true love. It's that kind of love that Christianity defines as "agape."

I have observed that younger generations have entirely lost sight of what giving love means. I see it in our culture and promoted in entertainment media. It's all about what "I" get out of something. This materialistic selfishness extends even to our relationships. I'm afraid, then, that my words probably bounce off ears that cannot comprehend them. Young folk look at older couples who have been together for half a century with befuddlement. They just don't get it and I haven't a clue how to explain it to people who were raised in this horrid culture.
 
tedgresham said:
I seems to me you're just saying something similar to what I am in a different way. Our views of what a relationship should be are entirely different. I have never entered into a relationship with the kind of expectations you have. Nobody owes me anything just because I love them. True love is given freely. It's a gift. When I give a gift it may or may not be appreciated but that's not the point. I love and/or care, depending on the relationship, hoping the same will be returned but never demanding it is. True love is not something we decide to have. It just happens. I hope it is returned but I would never demand it because it must happen in the other person. They cannot make it happen. If they do not have the same feeling for me then I have to accept that. If they do and I know it i do not worry about them, whether or not they will love someone else or have friends or whatever.

I might piss you off but I think what you said was rather sad. I love my wife. We do not have a perfect relationship, not relevant to this discussion, but the thing is, nothing she could ever do or say would change how I feel. She owes me nothing and I demand nothing. For over thirty years she has been the only person I've ever loved in this way. My wants/needs/desires are totally unimportant. This is true love. It's that kind of love that Christianity defines as "agape."

I have observed that younger generations have entirely lost sight of what giving love means. I see it in our culture and promoted in entertainment media. It's all about what "I" get out of something. This materialistic selfishness extends even to our relationships. I'm afraid, then, that my words probably bounce off ears that cannot comprehend them. Young folk look at older couples who have been together for half a century with befuddlement. They just don't get it and I haven't a clue how to explain it to people who were raised in this horrid culture.

No. We are not saying the same thing. You essentially just equated Love with a Relationship. The two are not interchangeable. You can have one without the other. You can spend the rest of your life loving somebody and never communicate with them or see them. You can spend the rest of your life sharing your bed with somebody you don't love.

Why did you get married? You had zero expectations, right? You didn't expect her to be around. Or to allow you to be around. You didn't expect her to put up with you behaving as if you love her. You didn't expect to share any portion of your life. Didn't expect to share a home, any meals, or any sort of emotional connection. You never figured that being married meant there would be somebody there to hold you when you're sad. Never expected her to turn to you when she's angry. No shared holidays or funerals. No sense of family or even friendship. Just two strangers oddly bound by the law.

I don't really care what generation you're talking about. If what I just described seems normal to you, you're the odd one out.
 
nerdygirl said:
No. We are not saying the same thing. You essentially just equated Love with a Relationship. The two are not interchangeable. You can have one without the other. You can spend the rest of your life loving somebody and never communicate with them or see them. You can spend the rest of your life sharing your bed with somebody you don't love.

I agree.

Why did you get married? You had zero expectations, right? You didn't expect her to be around. Or to allow you to be around. You didn't expect her to put up with you behaving as if you love her. You didn't expect to share any portion of your life. Didn't expect to share a home, any meals, or any sort of emotional connection. You never figured that being married meant there would be somebody there to hold you when you're sad. Never expected her to turn to you when she's angry. No shared holidays or funerals. No sense of family or even friendship. Just two strangers oddly bound by the law.

I don't really care what generation you're talking about. If what I just described seems normal to you, you're the odd one out.

Yeah, I'm the odd one, no question at all. I got married because I loved my wife. Still do, even more. What I expected and what I asked for are two different things. My wife and I have walked, stumbled, or whatever, through life together because we choose to. We choose to because we love each other. Over the years we've both been disappointed that the other has not lived up to one or the other expectations. But we've made no demands and we've accepted each other as we are. We have actually become very different people but none of that has changed how we feel for each other.

The difference between that and what you describe is that your relationship description is some kind of bargain, 'I give you love/myself and you give back because I do this giving.' Entering a relationship with that notion is a setup for failure. There are many things I've never been able to "give back" that my wife wanted. There's many times she has not "given back" too. Our commitment was not to feed each others needs, it was to give each other our love without condition. There is a massive difference. And it is a generational thing. If I approached our relationship as you describe I'd have left long ago. If my wife saw our relationship that way she'd have dumped me even sooner. The kind of relationship we have can't be explained, it has to be experienced. When you find such a relationship you will understand. Until then it will probably not make a lick of sense.
 
tedgresham said:
What I expected and what I asked for are two different things. My wife and I have walked, stumbled, or whatever, through life together because we choose to. We choose to because we love each other. Over the years we've both been disappointed that the other has not lived up to one or the other expectations. But we've made no demands and we've accepted each other as we are.

No. This isn't a generational thing. Marriage being an exchange of promises has been around since before Biblical times. I seriously doubt you're older than that. Despite your insistence that my youthful ignorance and cultural upbringing (which would be odd, given the fact that I was raised by an Asian farm girl) are the voice behind my sad and wrong words, you proved me right.

You implied you got married without any expectations or exchange of promises. Then you said your commitment was to give each other your love without condition. That is an exchange of promises. You said you've each been disappointed when the other failed to live up to expectations. That means there were expectations.

Assume in the following scenarios that your love remains unconditional and constant:
~If she no longer loved you, but said she would stay married to you, you would then be in a relationship in which you loved a woman unconditionally, and in which she allowed you to be married to her.

~If she no longer loved you and divorced you, you would no longer be in a relationship, but you would still love her unconditionally.

~If the two of you still loved each other, but felt you would be better off not not having any sort of relationship, you would both give unconditional Love, but have no relationship.

You see, at no point was your Love in any way altered by whether or not you were in a relationship. You can have the Love without the relationship. Your relationship does not have to be unconditional in order for your Love to be unconditional.

Just because your particular setup works for you, that doesn't mean it works for everybody. You chose your path not only because you love each other, but because you love your relationship. You can truly, sincerely, eternally love somebody and still know that you're better off without that person in your life (or vice versa). The fact that somebody decides that they have to leave, while you decided to stay does not invalidate that person's Love or make your Love somehow better than or more pure than their Love.
 
I'm pretty old. ha. Anyway, we're kind'f off the point, which was about being jealous. I said I believed jealousy was selfish, a kind of possessiveness. Nobody agreed with me but you know, that's usually the way it goes. Anyway, you said this:

nerdygirl said:
Each person comes into it with wants and needs to be met. They are saying, "I commit all of my affection to you and in return, you commit yours to me. We are each investing ourselves into this endeavor to be united." When somebody gets hurt that the other person is cheating, it isn't about some sense of entitlement or ownership. It's a betrayal of a trust and understanding.

The point I was trying to make, if somewhat poorly, was about how you put your statement. You said, "Each person comes into it with wants and needs to be met." My response is that entering into a relationship so that someone else will meet your needs is hardly unconditional love. The reverse is true. It should be, "I want to meet your needs because I love you." When the feelings are returned in the same way then a great emotional bond forms. So does trust.

Commitment always comes with risk, risk that the other one will not live up to expectations, will "fall out of love" with you, whatever. The same might happen to you. Rather than being jealous and responding to that jealousy the way a good relationship is maintained is by discussion and honesty.

I will admit I am different. I do not actually understand jealousy. I've never experienced it. I don't think I ever would. Whatever makes my wife happy is what I want, whether it's me or someone else. I don't care if nobody believes that, it's not the discussion.

The way you put your statement is absolutely a generational thing. Love and affection isn't, of course, but the approach people under 40 or so take to all of life is different. It's more self-serving. I see it all the time in most every place from those horrid Disney teen shows to movies and such. It's why I don't watch them and try to keep my kids away from them. Selflessness is old fashioned, blase', not productive. It does not matter who raised you or their culture or heritage. It oozes from the very center of modern society, this inward focus. Sadly much of my own generation is caught up in it too. The damned entertainment media.

Anyway, when the point of view is changed the likelihood of jealousy is greatly reduced. Maybe not eliminated, considering human nature, but lessened.

In your original post you said, "I'm a jealous person by nature. Usually just when it comes to guys though. I can't seem to make it STOP!!! " Then you asked, "Am I being a typical, insecure butt? Do I need to grow up and learn to trust?" My answer, from my perspective, is that you are being typical but not necessarily a butt. Whoever said youth is wasted on the young is so right. Everyone my age thinks that, "if only I could know what I know now." Can't be done.

The first thing I'd say is that you need a face to face discussion with him to determine if his feelings are truly genuine. The phone and especially the net will never speak the volumes his expression will. Start the discussion and you'll know. You'll also know just how deep and sincere your relationship is. If you know without a doubt he's the guy for your lifetime and believe he thinks the same way then consider how you can make him happy and try it. Forget your needs for a while. If the feelings are anything less then just talk and discuss your expectations, set parameters, talk honestly. So few people take that approach these days. It'll answer lots of your questions and solve your worries over jealousy too, I think.

Last of all, yeah, you just might be hurt. Live is a world of hurts with a few glorious days of joy tossed in for balance. But don't let your fear of being hurt (which could be fueling your excessive jealousy) keep you from living.
 
What Im saying is Jealousy is just another human emotions.

It's like fears....everyone have feelings of fears.
Everyone have feelings of insecurities.

"Nothing to fear but fear itself."
Bascailly its saying the samething. Stop making a mountain out of a mole hill.

If you percieve jealousy as sometype of morbid fiber. it'll feed more into the fire.

If you're awear that it's just another normal human emotions. it'll take the power
out of it. The same is true for fears.

You can pyscho annylize the **** out of it.
Such as...Jealousy, or anger is a secondary emotion to fears.


If a person takes the time sits down and observe their emotions or behaviors patterns.
Whats really going on inside of them....it'll be rreally benifitual to them.
Instead of going round and round in circle of outside circunstance, surface stuff
or whatever the **** moral and vaules...which complicates the living **** out of everything.

So when feelings of fears comes up...how dose a person react or respond to it.

Fear will stop you in your tracks.
Fear will also get you off of your ***.

So when a person gose into obsessing about her BF on FB or whatever else...
She's bascially just reacting to her fears...getting off of her *** to do something about her life.
Her security had been threathen.
The same happens when you see a snake....you instintively jump to a safe place or kill the fucken snake.
It's realitively this simple.

Is there sometime wrong with her?
"NO"

Yeah...Jealousy is fucken overratted. It's not sometype deformity.
It's simply learning how to repsond to it, instead of reacting to our basic instinks.

Such as starting this thread...she's responding...taking time to think things through.

See here's the deal...
Notice the way you write or express yourself...
BEING jealouse...you're identifying yourself as your emotions...

Such as BEING angery...

If you simply write things in a different ways or see things differently..
Such as..
You FEEL Jealous.
You FEEL Anger.
You FEEL Threaten.
ect...ect

You''ll saperate yourself from you're emotions and not be dragged about by your emotions.

We all have FEELINGS.
We are not our FEELINGS

You'll simply will also know you have the power and chioce to chose your feelings....

Therfore taking control back of your own life.
 
tedgresham... I NEVER said that. You don't even know who you're talking to anymore.

Each person does enter a relationship with wants and needs to be met. Period. I did not say a thing about unconditional love. You did. Once you did, I explained that Love is Love, and Relationships are Relationships, which are not the same thing. There is nothing wrong with the original poster knowing what she wants out of a relationship, and she can love somebody without being in a relationship with him.
 
I love how EVERYONE is just lumped into the same group -_-. I'm under 40 so I have to think a certain way! Yay :p
 

Latest posts

Back
Top